I went car shopping this month and came home radicalized. A used truck, four years old, 60,000 miles, priced higher than it sold for new in 2021. When I pointed this out, the salesman said that’s just the market, in the tone people use for weather. It is not weather, Brian. Someone is setting these numbers.
So I did what I do, spreadsheets, price histories, reliability data. Here are nine popular vehicles where the price and the product have genuinely lost contact with each other.
1. Full-size pickup trucks, almost all of them
The average new truck transaction crossed $65,000, for a category where most buyers tow nothing and haul groceries. Trucks became luxury goods wearing work clothes, and the markup is the costume fee. The 2012 version of the same truck did the same actual jobs for half the inflation-adjusted price.
2. The used trucks those buyers trade in
Used full-size trucks hold value so absurdly that four-year-old models with real mileage list within 10 percent of new. Paying 90 percent of new price for 40 percent of the vehicle’s life is the worst deal on any lot, and it’s somehow the most popular one in America.
3. The Jeep Wrangler
everyone’s uncle owns one, so let me apologize in advance. The Wrangler charges a premium for off-road ability that the overwhelming majority of owners use zero times per year, while delivering fuel economy, ride quality, and reliability scores from another decade. You’re paying $50,000 for an identity, and the identity gets 19 miles per gallon on the way to an office park.
4. Compact SUVs with luxury badges
The entry luxury crossovers are mechanically their mainstream cousins in nicer suits, sharing platforms, engines, and factories, at $12,000 to $18,000 more. The badge costs more than every actual upgrade combined. Cross-shop the mainstream twin and the money practically refunds itself.
5. Anything with a dealer market adjustment sticker
The second sticker with $3,000 to $10,000 of pure vibes added to hot models. It has no product behind it, it’s a patience tax, charged to whoever won’t wait three months or drive to a dealership two towns over. The car isn’t overpriced, the transaction is, which is somehow more insulting.
6. Three-row SUVs bought for one week a year
Families pay a $10,000 plus premium over the two-row version for third-row seats used on one annual trip. A minivan does the job better for less, but the minivan has an image problem, so the market charges accordingly. The overprice here is emotional, the invoice is real.
7. Off-road trim packages on mall crawlers
The rugged trims, special badges, all-terrain tires, skid plates, add $5,000 to $12,000 for capability that requires terrain the vehicle will never see. Buyers pay for the possibility of adventure. Possibility is the highest-margin product in the car business.
8. Certified pre-owned German luxury sedans
The certification adds a warranty and a fat markup to vehicles entering their expensive years. The depreciation curve that makes these cars tempting exists because the repair costs are coming, the certification just delays the introduction. The $38,000 certified sedan with $2,400 annual maintenance is not the deal the sticker suggests.
9. New EVs from legacy brands’ first attempts
The first-generation electric models from traditional automakers carry premium prices with early-adopter problems, software issues, charging quirks, brutal depreciation. The same money buys the established competitor, and the two-year-old used version of these exact cars costs 40 percent less, which tells you what the market really thinks the technology is worth.
What I actually bought
A boring three-year-old sedan from a brand nobody posts about, with a reliability record like a toaster. It cost what cars are supposed to cost. Nobody at a stoplight will ever compliment it, and that, it turns out, is the discount.
Wrangler owners, the comment section is yours, I accept my fate. Everyone else, what car price genuinely shocked you recently?
Amelia writes Cents That Count from her kitchen table. She has quit four budgeting apps, run one no spend month, tracked every small purchase for 60 days, and still buys coffee. Everything here is tested on a real, ordinary budget first.
More about this blog →