Every list like this promises you’ll save thousands by giving up things you love. This is not that list. I tried giving up things I love once. It lasted three weeks and ended with a revenge purchase that undid two months of discipline.
So I went the other way. Over the last two years I paid attention to which purchases I actually missed after they were gone. These nine turned out to be things I bought out of habit, marketing, or some vague idea of what adults are supposed to own.
Cutting them saves me roughly $2,300 a year. And I can honestly say I don’t think about a single one of them.
1. Paper towels, mostly
We were a two rolls a week household. Now a stack of cheap washable rags handles most of the mess, and one roll of paper towels lasts a month for the genuinely gross jobs. Savings, about $180 a year. Effort, learning where the rag drawer is.
2. The “good” version of pantry staples
I ran my own blind taste test. Store brand against name brand for flour, sugar, canned tomatoes, butter, oats, and frozen vegetables. I picked out the name brand twice in ten tries. One of those times I liked the store brand better anyway.
Swapping staples saves us $30 to $40 a month. My pancakes have received zero complaints.
3. Greeting cards
$5.99 for cardboard that gets read for eleven seconds. I keep a box of blank cards now, twelve dollars for twenty, and I write something actually personal inside. Twice, someone has kept one on their fridge. Nobody ever fridged a store bought card with a golfing cartoon on it.
4. Single purpose kitchen gadgets
The avocado slicer. The egg cooker. The quesadilla maker, which made exactly four quesadillas before retiring to the cabinet of broken dreams. A knife and a pan do all of it. My kitchen drawers finally close.
5. Bottled water for the house
A filter pitcher and two decent bottles ended a $25 a month case of water habit. I resisted this one for years because tap water felt like a downgrade. Through the filter it tastes identical. It was always going to taste identical. Marketing is powerful and I was its loyal customer.
6. A new phone every two years
My phone is four years old. It takes photos, runs my banking app, and receives the same group chat complaints a new one would. Skipping one upgrade cycle saved about $800. That’s a vacation. Or four months of groceries. In my case it became most of an emergency fund deposit.
7. Dryer sheets
Wool dryer balls, bought once three years ago, still going. I cannot detect any difference in the laundry. I simply stopped paying for a product whose entire job is making towels smell like a meadow for six minutes.
8. Books I’ll read “someday”
This one hurt. I love owning books. But my honest ratio of bought to read was about four to one, which means I was paying full price for decoration.
The library app gets me almost everything within a week or two. I still buy books I’ve already read and loved. My shelf is a trophy case now instead of a guilt museum. That mindset shift, that frugal isn’t the same as joyless, is the whole subject of frugal versus cheap.
9. Lottery tickets
I was a casual player. Five dollars here, ten when the jackpot made the news. Maybe $250 a year. My lifetime winnings, I checked, came to $34.
I moved the habit to a savings account I named Jackpot. It pays out every single time. Finally, a rigged game I can get behind.
The pattern behind all nine
None of these were sacrifices. They were subscriptions to old versions of myself. Habits nobody had audited in years.
That’s the real move here. Not cutting joy. Firing the purchases that stopped delivering any. Go through last month’s statement and ask each line, would I actually miss you? The honest answer is no more often than you think.
Amelia writes Cents That Count from her kitchen table. She has quit four budgeting apps, run one no spend month, tracked every small purchase for 60 days, and still buys coffee. Everything here is tested on a real, ordinary budget first.
More about this blog →